Ignition Switch Key
Breakage Tech Article
Originally posted Nov 2014, revisions ongoing. R. Kwas
Broken Key Syndrome
Broken Ignition Key
Lock Cylinder Removal
Leaving Ignition ON with Engine not Running
Ignition Switch Positions and Function
Keys Broken by Third Parties
Late-Production Ignition Switch
Background: As this is an often discussed topic on the Fora, usually after a new owner posts of having broken a key, or looking for advice on what to do when one breaks the Ignition Key in the Ignition Switch, and I answer, finishing with a recommendation to “install a SwEm Kit Pushbutton Start Switch to prevent reoccurrence”, I thought it was time to do a bit of an in-depth-analysis and root-cause-investigation on the subject…
One of the low moments of vintage Volvo ownership.
Ignition Switch Position 4.
Please Use the Correct Terminology! For the purpose of this article (and I suggest any discussions on this subject elsewhere) the Ignition Switch Assembly consists of the *Lock Cylinder (LC) and Electrical Switch section (ES).
Uniqueness: The Bosch supplied Ignition Switch of the Volvo 544,122, 1800 vehicles are unique in several ways. The Ignition Switch (IS) is actually part of an assembly combined with the Ignition Coil, and both are permanently connected by an Armored Cable. LINK With this arrangement, the Ignition Power node could be made internal, inaccessible and completely protected within the assembly. It is therefore impossible to “Hot –Wire” these vehicles, or Start the engine without the Key applying power to the Ignition System. At the Ignition Coil located in the engine compartment (refer to graphic below), the observant reader will notice only one terminal in addition to the High Voltage output, where typically the Ignition power node would also be located.
Another way the Ignition Sys differs from other systems of the day is that it has no Ballast Resistor. Lack of a Ballast Resistor is outside the scope of this consideration and covered elsewhere on the SwEm site. LINK1
Also, the difference this article will concentrate on is that the force required to turn the Key into the momentary Start position seems the highest of any vehicle I’ve ever experienced.
FIGURE 1. Ignition Switch/Armored Cable/Coil Assembly
Source: GPCs Site with my mark-ups.
Security: The inaccessible Ignition Power node was an effective anti-theft measure of its day. Unless a thief had the forethought to bring and wire in his own Ignition Coil, or had access to a flatbed car-mover or cargo helicopter with which to airlift the vehicle away, I don’t suppose too many of these vehicles got stolen.
Broken Key Syndrome: A weakness that a number of owners have unfortunately experienced firsthand, which develops after years of ownership (and more specifically, thousands of times turning the Ignition Key), is that it is not uncommon for the Ignition Key to twist off as one is turning it to the momentary Start position. Inspecting the failure site, it looks like the breakage is a result of Cumulative Cyclic Fatigue…it’s a real bother, but I believe well understood and explained at this point and addressed by Preventative Measures! From the first day of ownership, it always seemed to me that the turning force required to go to the Start position was on the high side…years later, when I broke my first key, confirming my suspicions that the key was overworked, did I think about it, recognize and accept the cause as Cyclic, Cumulative Fatigue and coin the term “Gorilla Spring”.
Why is the Gorilla Spring so strong? The Gorilla Spring is a spring whose function it is to return the electrical starting contact of the Ignition Switch from the momentary Starting Position 4 back to the Ignition ON Position 3 after engine has started and the Key is released. (See: Reference Information - Ignition Switch Positions and Function below). I expect Bosch engineers felt it important to assure the Gorilla Spring disengages the Solenoid contact, as failure to release it would keep the Starter/Solenoid engaged which would be a pretty big problem. (Link to Starter Tech Article, which includes detailed Solenoid info: http://www.sw-em.com/starter.htm )
Lubrication Issues: Keeping the LC well lubricated so that it doesn’t contribute any appreciable counterforce to being turned is certainly important. I suggest Tri-Flow light non-synthetic, Teflon containing oil for this. Tri-Flow has a high film strength, and works splendidly in this application. I have yet to see it gum up or disappoint in any way.
The ES was lubed at construction and as it has sealed bulkhead between LC and the ES, it is not possible to add any lube here. Having disassembled switches and looked behind the curtain, the grease used does tend to "dry" somewhat (what does one expect after half a century?), but I have not seen it add appreciably to the force needed to turn the ES. The sealed bulkhead also means that no amount of lube applied into the LC will serve to lube the ES decreasing the force needed to turn it…of course, no amount of lube will change a spring’s spring-constant anyway!
"Weak Keys" are no Explanation. Broken Volvo Keys have been explained (wrongly!) in that they are somehow weaker than other keys…this is just not the case! Volvo Ignition Keys are of typical construction and strength and available various metals …from aluminum to brass, to chrome plated brass, to steel, and they all seem to break...so it’s pretty clear that it is not weakness of the Key, but the overwhelming cause is the Gorilla Spring in the Ignition Switch itself. Since the mechanism of failure is cumulative metal fatigue, the specific metal key is made of only serves to vary how many cycles the key will survive before the inevitable breakage.
…so the Big Question
is: What is different between the Bosch Ignition Switch Assembly and millions
of automotive Ignition Switches in existence, which makes the Volvo one
predisposed to eating Keys?
My Answer: The Lock Cylinder is a Gearbox! If the LC is removed from the Electrical Switch (See also: Additional Information: Divide and Conquer), so that the Tailpiece movement can be observed as the key is turned, it will be noted that the tailpiece actually turns through more degrees of arc than the key, so there is a “gearing up action” taking place. This gearing (up) effect of LC (seen from key perspective) is effectively a torque multiplier for the force of the Gorilla Spring …in other words, the Gorilla Spring has a mechanical advantage over the key, and this turns out to be the big contributing factor to the fatigue .
FIGURE 2. Key vs Tailpiece Angular Travel Study Setup. Lock Cylinder is secured in soft-jawed vice (Key removal/insertion position vertical), color coded stick extensions have been temporarily added to Key and Tailpiece, and angular travel is marked on paper behind (on-axis!). Not super accurate, but quite effective to make the point. Note also that in the picture, Key is shown in Position 4 without any force necessary to keep it there. This is because the LC is uninstalled so Gorilla Spring is not even present to act on the tailpiece and return it to Pos 3.
My careful measurement of the rotation of the Key (90degrees) vs. the Tailpiece (120degrees) calculates to a ratio of 1.33. This is the additional mechanical advantage of the Gorilla Spring over the key, because looking at this system from the standpoint of the Gorilla Spring it means that any torque which needs to be applied to the Key to turn it against the Gorilla Spring, must be divided by this ratio…and the force of the Gorilla Spring we feel when turning the key is also amplified by this ratio! In other words, the key must supply MORE torque than if the turning action was connected directly at 1:1. It's a losing proposition for the key, and this is the big difference between this particular LC and Ignition Switches of other vehicles. My locksmith reference (thanks Paul S.!) informs me that this gearing within the LC is unique to vintage Volvos, (and apparently also vintage Saabs, confirmed by my vintage Saab specialist acquaintance Paul M.).
Given this design weakness, I make the statement that "All vintage Volvo keys will break eventually!" Those owners who have not yet had this less-than-wonderful experience, can consider themselves lucky, but can still expect breakage in the future, after their key has accumulated some more stress cycles! See: Additional information: Cumulative Cyclic Fatigue
After you install one of these gorgeous, shiny new, reasonably priced new Lock Cylinders from CVI, you will still be best served by installing a SwEm Kit Pushbutton Start Switch which will leave that new key looking great and operating without fatigue, for a long, long time...probably to outlive you!
Source: CVI's site: http://www.cvi-automotive.se/en/articles/2.14418.44450/ignition-lock-barrel-with-2-keys-pvduettaz-58-68-p ...my comments added!
YouTube Video of Ignition Switch disassembly and internal inspection. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=hfuUbguT9Gw
Frame capture from video showing the Gorilla Spring.
[...he does use some incorrect terminology like "tumbler" when he should be calling it "lock cylinder", and I prefer the term "detents" to "nubs", but I'll get over it...him posting this video means I don't have to... Things to note in the video are how Lock Cylinder is COMPLETELY SEALED from the Electrical Switch (so NO amount of lube we saturate the Lock Cylinder with will make its way to the Electrical Switch OR Gorilla Spring), and how his thumb is actually on the Gorilla Spring from about 1:35 on...at 1:50 he simply calls it a spring and breezes over it...finally, the posting is labeled 1969 1800, it is however applicable and representative of all earlier Volvos. '69 was actually the last year this style LC and key were used on the 1800. This was the change-over year when the factory went to 140 style LCs and keys.]
Link to: Extracting a Broken Ignition Key
*The Lock Cylinder (LC) (PN ASSA 657291-1 or Nieman PN ????) is Removable for Replacement!
(Refer to picture below) To remove the LC, the Key is necessary. It should be inserted into the LC, and turned to the Ignition ON, Position 3 (see below!). The Retaining Button is then located behind the dashboard, protruding through the LC Retaining Hole in the ES housing collar, and depressed with a Pick tool or similar. This should cause LC with key to be pushed out, and allow simple extraction. If the spring which preloads into the tailpiece does not push the LC out at this point, a bit of additional wiggling of the Key should allow the LC assembly to be removed.
Nieman Lock Cylinder, showing two OE key styles available.
If LC needs to be removed because key has been broken off, it is likely already in the Ignition ON, Position 3. Disconnect Battery to prevent Ignition Coil overheating (see Note 1) and remove LC by depressing Retaining Pin.
“Drilling out the LC” is an extreme, violent act which some (strictly amateur!) Locksmiths might want to do as an easy option (for them!), but I recommend against. It is unlikely the vintage ES will survive this act completely unharmed! If the LC needs to be removed and a key is not available, this should be done by insisting that locksmith “pick the lock” to the Ignition ON Position (3) OR that the make a "Key by Impression" and use that to turn the LC to Position (3). Temporarily disconnect Battery during this work, to prevent Ignition Coil overheating - again...see Note 1, before depressing the Retention Button, and removing the LC.
Once LC is removed, ES can then be turned with a flat-blade screwdriver inserted into the slot which the Tailpiece normally turns, while organizing a replacement (see CVI info above, and Options 1-3 below!).
New Keys after Key Breakage:
Option 1. "Key by Impression", is an Locksmith's technique by which they use a new key blank to make a key when none is available (or as is the case for us, the key is in two pieces, in which case, they will probably recommend Option 2). The technique requires the LC be presented to them (which might pose a problem if it is still part of the car and hasn't been removed yet!), or them to be called to the location of the car (expensive road-call!). It also requires key fragment to first be removed, but Locksmiths have their tools and techniques for this.
Option 2. Extracting the broken key fragment from LC, and having the Locksmith use it, along with a new key blank, to cut a "new" replacement key. The operation is much like copying a whole key, except takes a bit more care on the part of the Locksmith.
Option 3. Getting two new keys when replacing the LC. Not nearly as much fun or creative as Options 1 or 2, and likely more expensive too...
Recommendation: Options 1-3 should be followed by the installation of a SW-EM Start Switch Upgrade Kit because the reader, (and most others of his species) has evolved to have opposable thumbs, walk upright, (and a few others have further evolved to drive a vintage Volvo), and is therefore intelligent, smart and capable of learning from past experience. Reference: Evolvolution
Note 1. Leaving Ignition ON with Engine not Running is not good practice! When Ignition Switch is in the Ignition ON Position 3, for the purpose of removing LC, but engine has not been started, Ignition Coil power node has power applied...the entire time! If Ignition Points, happen to also be closed at this time, it means Ignition Coil Primary current is flowing constantly and uninterrupted (compared to normal operation while engine is running). If this condition persists, Ignition Coil will overheat and can be damaged. Temporarily disconnect vehicle Battery to prevent this. A reminder of this is the orange OIL and red AMP Indicators are lit brightly for an extended time.
Fatigue: Cyclic or Cumulative Fatigue (in the Torsional (twisting) mode.
According to a popular on-line reference:
”Fatigue occurs when a material is subjected to repeated loading and unloading.”…sound familiar? A cute example of where we might intentionally use Cyclic Cumulative Fatigue is if you collect pop-tops from beverage cans for the charities. One will rarely liberate the pop-tops with the first bend…the tab is intended to stay connected to the can (that’s the whole point of why they were made “unremovable” in the seventies)…but after several more back and forth cycles, with the metal becoming more weak at every cycle, the pop-top finally beaks away…Cyclic Cumulative Fatigue has had the desired effect, and the reader has just read another groovy practical analogy by yours truly!!
Measures to Prevent Key Breakage: Change
the rules(!), by making it so that the Ignition Key never has to be turned to
the very stressful momentary Starting Position 4 ever again! LINK A
SwEm Kit Pushbutton Start Switch
Additional Info: Consideration of SwEm Start Pushbutton particularly the interaction with an electronic ignition module.
Divide and Conquer. Having a watershed moment in troubleshooting, when one can definitely say it’s this or that is always handy, and here is one of those cases. Removing the * LC allows one to turn the key in the LC without any load on its Tailpiece. One can then easily see the high force to turn the key is not because of the LC resistance, but because of the Gorilla Spring in the Electrical Switch part...and one can also observe the gearing effect!
Ignition Switch Positions and Function (including action of Gorilla Spring):
Swept angle of Key, between Pos1 and 4, is shown. This is consistent with experimental measurements made in FIGURE 2 above.
Keys Broken by Third Parties:
...from an E-mail on the subject: "Every time I send the car for repair/service it comes back with a broken key." ...this has happened to me also, not that I send my vehicle out for work by other parties a lot, but I was having a windshield replaced...one of the few jobs I leave to local auto glass shop experts.
For those that might at some point need to let someone else have occasion to start the car...like when the car has to be left with other people for service, I suggest temporarily sticking a big piece of tape next to the Ignition Switch with the words:
DO NOT TURN KEY TO MOMENTARY START POSITION!
TO START, TURN IGNITION ON WITH KEY, THEN PRESS START BUTTON!
...and before you leave "Your Baby" with them, you might want to point this out, plus the location of your Start Pushbutton...hopefully that will prevent disappointments!
Your Baby, at the shop!
Late-Production Ignition Switch with integrated Steering Lock:
Late Ignition Switch (fitted to the last Amazons from about '69) is not as susceptible to key fatigue as the early Ign Switch as it uses a different mechanism (NO gearing or Gorilla Spring) and a 140 style key. The later switch is identifiable in that it is located not in the dashboard, but on the Steering Column. This allows the Steering Lock feature to be incorporated.
Pictures courtesy Simon, used with his kind permission.
Late-Production Ignition Switch with integral Steering Column Lock provision.
Late-Production Ignition Switch, Key position, terminal function and wiring detail.
Note: Terminal 57a on this switch has power applied in the "Locked" position. This terminal and function is not present in the early Dashboard located switches.*
* Term 57a is used to power low power lamps of the "Standing Light" in Germany (and possibly other countries on the continent), while parked, to light corners and increase visibility of the car when parked protruding out onto narrow, dark streets. It could conceivably be used to power an alarm system.
An interesting issue came to light recently when reassembling a Dashboard. Although wires and their location had been recorded at time of disassembly, the (smaller of the two) Black wires (Lights Power) was wrongly reconnected to the 57a Terminal. Given that this Term only gets power when in the 0 - Locked Position, that meant the Lights could only be turned on, in this Key position...the author could not explain this action, because on the earlier Ignition Switch, there in no terminal which is powered only when Ignition is OFF. Again, once it was realized that it was a late Ignition Switch was in play, the answer and explanation became clear.
Link to Thread: Ignition Switch Wiring: http://www.volvoforums.org.uk/showthread.php?t=266985
Unless otherwise attributed, the information here is Copyright© 2015 - 2018, by R. Kwas. The terms Volvo, Bosch, CVI, ASSA, and Nieman are used for reference only. I have no affiliation with any of these companies, other than to try to keep their products working for me, and to help other enthusiasts try to do the same. The results presented here are from my own experience, and can be ridiculed, laughed at, used for your entertainment or worshipped...your call! As always, you are responsible for your own knuckles. If you can supply additional objective information or experience, I will consider it, and consider working it into the next revision of this article...along with likely the odd metaphor and maybe wise-a** comment.
You are welcome to use the information here in good health, and for your own non-commercial purposes, but if you reprint or otherwise republish this article, you must give credit to the author or link back to the SwEm site as the source. If you don’t, you’re just a lazy, scum sucking plagiarist, and the Boston Globe wants you! As always, if you can supply corrections, or additional objective information or experience, I will always consider it, and consider working it into the next revision of this article...along with likely the odd metaphor, practical analogy and possibly wise-a** comment.